background
Lectionary Commentary
February 29, 2004
First Sunday in Lent

See also: [Year C Archive]

Lenten Candle Liturgy
Sermon [2007]
Lent Benedictions


Psalm 91:1-2, 9-16
Deuteronomy 26:1-11
Romans 10:8b-13
Luke 4:1-13

If one wished to find a link among these four texts for the first Sunday of Lent of 2004 it appears to be the confession of faith.  Bear this in mind as we go through the reading of each of these texts in turn, inverting the last two for reasons that will become apparent.

Deuteronomy 26:1-11
Deut 26:1-11 is a grand text, taken by interpreters to be the confession of the great themes that organize the Pentateuch or Torah:  Patriarchal wandering, liberation from Egyptian slavery, guidance in the wilderness, and possession of the land promised to the forefathers and foremothers.  The absence of the theme of Sinai and the giving of the law has at times been a matter of concern, and Martin Noth in his great works on the tradition history of the Pentateuch postulated on the basis of its absence here and in other similar confessions elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible outside the Torah that originally these were two different traditions, (1) the redemption of Israel and its reception of the land and (2) the covenant at Sinai.  This thesis has not held up under investigation and is no longer considered useful as an explanation, in spite of its fruitfulness for research.

So we are left with the confession of the Israelite who, when he (always masculine) enters the land, will publicly confess that the benefits of this rich land are the gift of YHWH who has therewith fulfilled the promises to the forefathers (and foremothers).  This is not due to the power of Israelite arms nor the wisdom of his own agricultural techniques.  This is the wondrous work of God.  “My forefather was a wandering Aramean,” apparently a reference to Jacob, and now I am the possessor of a land that flows with milk and honey, thanks to YHWH.  The links between the landlessness of Jacob and the fruitful land enjoyed “today” are the redemption of Israel from Egypt and the guidance through the wilderness, both wonders of the mighty hand and outstretched arm of YHWH.  I hereby confess it publicly.

V 11 is noteworthy.  After the confession the Israelite is to “rejoice.”  And he is not to rejoice alone but with “the Levite and the alien (ger).”  Now, rejoice here clearly means to partake of the meat and grain offered on the altar, and to do so accompanied by those who do not have land, the levite because his portion is YHWH and the ger because he is a foreigner and must work on the land of others.  Although the word justice does not appear the idea that Paul will develop of justice as a consequence of faith is in fact present in the Deuteronomy law.  The alien whose presence in the land is precarious is to enjoy the fruits of the land along with the Israelite who confesses his faith in these fruits as gifts from God.

Within the Torah this fulfillment has not yet happened.  The Torah ends with the death of Moses, the prophet of YHWH, who has seen the promised land from the peak of Mount Nebo in the plains of Moab but has not stepped on the land (Deut 34:1-8).  So that really what the Israelite is confessing when he brings his first fruits and fulfils this commandment is his faith that God will fulfill God’s promises.  The setting for the final composition of the Torah was the Persian province of Yehud some time between 538 b.c.e., when the exiles in Babylon were allowed to return, and 332 b.c.e., when Alexander conquered Palestine.  For most Jews today, who still live in the Diaspora, this is still a confession of faith.  Christians likewise are here ordered to confess their faith that the final word in this world that seems messed up is the triumph of God.

Psalm 91:1-2, 9-16
In commenting on the Ash Wednesday Psalm reading (Ps 51) it was said that the most numerous category of psalms is that of the individual’s petition or lament.  And it was added that in these psalms there are three narrative personae, the psalmist, God and the enemy of the psalmist who is presented as an evil-doer (po`ale’ ‘aven). Psalm 91 is not a psalm of lament or petition. But it takes an element that appears in some of those psalms and develops it by itself.  This is the confession of redemption before “the poor,” an element developed in Ps 22:23-25 (Hebrew, 25-28 in most English versions). Once the psalmist has been saved from the threat posed by the enemy, he gathers the assembly of the poor to declare what God has done and to share with them the meat of his sacrifice of thanksgiving.

In the case of the psalm of petition the sequence is the same as in the Deuteronomy text we have examined:  redemption and then confession.  Part of the confession is rejoicing in the same sense as the rejoicing in Deuteronomy and with a gathering of the same outsiders to be gathered for the festival, according to Deuteronomy.  The difference is that in Deuteronomy we are dealing with the whole people of Israel represented by each and every Israelite.  In the psalms of lament each Israelite pours out his or her case before YHWH and expects an answer to be followed by the celebration of YHWH’s fidelity.

Very well, let us turn now to Psalm 91.  This is a psalm of confession or witness to God’s faithfulness.  It is as if a section of the psalms of lament was lifted and made into a separate psalm, a psalm of witness to God’s fidelity.  According to my count, there are four such psalms in our canonical collection, Psalms 32, 34, 91, and 138.  The psalm we have for today’s reading is obviously one of them.  The portion that relates the victory of YHWH over the psalmist’s enemy or enemies (vv 3-8) has been omitted in the selection for today, but it is important in that it shows that this psalm has the same three personae of the psalms of lament.

Since this is a psalm of testimony God is not its addressee. The psalmist is not asking anything from God or even thanking God for the deliverance from his enemies. The addressees are not named, but perhaps we can assume that they are the levite and the alien mentioned in Deuteronomy in a similar context or the poor mentioned in Psalm 22. In any case, the psalmist is not addressing God (in thankfulness) or the enemy (to gloat at his defeat). This psalm bears witness to the poor to the wonders God has done in liberating the psalmist from his enemies.

Now, in the last two verses there is a shift.  Without warning, God speaks, and God does so to the same gathered ones to whom the psalmist has been confessing.  To those who love me (bi chashaq, literally “are joined to me”) I will place on high (‘asaggav), that is, in a place of protection”  (v 14).  “I will be with him in times of trouble” (v 15).  And “I will make him enjoy length of days and make him see my salvation (yeshu`ati, the same root from which Jesus comes and also hosanna)”.  How are we to imagine the delivery of these words of God in the midst of the celebration by the psalmist?  Perhaps a prophet, or perhaps they are liturgical expressions like many we use in our worship.

This psalm does pose a theological problem.  Are those who “adhere to” or “love” God to expect to be protected from all harm?  I think the answer is obviously not.  Bad things do happen to believers.  I believe that we are expected to live confidently and not to fear evil around every corner.  In a society where a terrorist lurks in every school and in every public bus or street no community can be established.  Knowing that bad things do happen once in a while, we must act on the presumption that the street we are walking down is safe and that the people we will cross on the sidewalk are well-meaning people.  FDR said famously, “We have nothing to fear but fear itself.”  As believers we must reject the reaction of many, leaders and not leaders, to the lamentable attacks on the World Commerce Towers and the Pentagon, a reaction that urges us to live in constant fear and to trust nobody.  Instead of looking for terrorists under every stone, couldn’t we better ask why these presumably reasonable people attacked these public symbols of U.S. economic and military power?  Let us not demonize the enemy but trust that God will protect us from harm if we treat all with the respect they deserve as creatures of God, even those called “terrorists” by fearful people.

Romans 10:8b-13
Chapters 9 to 11 of Paul’s Epistle to the Romans is a long section on the eventual incorporation of the Jewish nation into the Christian community, an eventuality that Paul felt guaranteed by the promises to Israel.  The portion assigned for the First Sunday of Lent centers around the central concepts of Paul’s theological argument in this epistle:  Faith, justification (dikaóõ, to make just), and salvation.  In order to properly place this whole argument about Israel it is useful to remember that the emperor Claudius (who governed 41 to 54) had expelled the Jews from Rome, meaning that the Christians in that city were no doubt still in the late 50s predominantly Gentiles.  As the Jews return, Paul wants them to be received well by their Gentile brothers and sisters, knowing that they are the recipients of promises from God.

From Rom 1:18-32 it is clear that Paul believes that the acclaimed Roman law is impotent to make people just, in their conduct toward others and in God’s eyes.  The justice of God is revealed in the faith of Jesus, which we have seen manifest in the story of the temptations, as it communicates with our faith.  Faith is also revealed in Abraham’s willingness to leave his land for an unknown promised land (Rom 4).  It is this faith that enables humans to become just as they release control over their justice and believe that God will make the outcome right.  In Rom 10:9 the content of faith is belief in the resurrection of Jesus Christ.  The first to believe was Jesus himself, who gave his fortunes over to the Roman soldiers in confidence that God could and would raise whatever the soldiers left to full life.  We do not know what exactly happened on Easter Sunday, but God did one way or another vindicate that Jesus whom the authorities had crucified as a subversive.  We believe with Jesus that God can and will give new life where life has been denied.  In a globalized market like today’s that denies to most people life in its plenitude while granting to a minority ridiculous sums of money that they cannot ever use, one can easily lose heart and give up.  To follow Jesus is to believe in his resurrection and that of our poor world.

But Paul proposes a second step:  “For with the heart one believes for justice, but with the mouth one confesses for salvation” (Rom 10:10).  One becomes just only by believing.  If we give up believing that God will give new life to this exhausted world we shall no longer have the energy it takes to challenge its structures, to be just.  But when we believe and act justly in accordance with our belief we must not keep our faith to ourselves but must proclaim it.  This is the witness or public confession we saw in Deut 26 and Ps 91.  Whoever believes will not be ashamed.  This we should proclaim and gain more who are willing to struggle against the dominant current of our times on behalf of life for all, Jew and Greek (and Vietnamese and Iraqi and Zimbabwean).

All who publicly call on the name of Jesus Christ, crucified and risen from the dead, “will be saved (sosthesetai)” (Rom 10:13).  Saved from what, we may and should ask?  Paul’s answer is, “from the wrath that is coming” (1 Thess. 1:10).  What is the wrath that is coming?  We do not know exactly what Paul had in mind in the mid-First Century, but as we begin the Twenty-First the nature of that wrath is frighteningly clear:  Global warming, oceans polluted with mercury and other toxic substances that kill Eskimo babies in the Arctic, countless plant and animal species that disappear forever, in general an ecological catastrophe of proportions we cannot really calculate.  And right now, not tomorrow, millions of babies are undernourished and condemned to live short lives with few of the foods and shelter that sustain full human life.  This is the coming wrath that is already upon us.  The Resurrection means that there is salvation from this wrath.  We who believe are called upon to bear witness to a God who created and continues to create and sustain life where humans and nature itself seem to condemn it.  If we live in the justice enabled by faith and proclaim to all the life-giving possibilities that God offers, there is indeed hope of salvation.  This is a message worth proclaiming this Lent of 2004!

Luke 4:1-13
This story of the temptations of Jesus is best read as a model for us as disciples, followers that is of Jesus.  Like the baptism, the temptation at Gethsemane, the cross on Calvary, and the resurrection, these are stories to be studied as guides for our living. In this one the devil makes his appearance. The devil is a very infrequent presence in the stories of Jesus. Unlike the Satan of the book of Job, who is an accuser, or the dragon who is the devil or Satan in the Revelation of John, who is a persecutor and evil-doer, the devil here is a tempter.

Somehow we are to understand that Jesus’ temptations are also temptations we face.  This is perhaps clearer in the Gethsemane story, where Jesus knows the danger he faces and is tempted to hide or run away.  Hiding or running from the enemy can always be justified.  St. Cyprian did it during the terrible persecution by Decian in 251, in order to lead his flock from the protection of his hiding place.  Jesus surely had a better excuse. His disciples had shown on the way to Jerusalem that they were not ready to face danger, and his continued presence could surely have strengthened their resolve.  But Jesus understood that the time was ripe for him to face down his enemies and the enemies of the Jewish people, the Jewish and Roman authorities in Jerusalem.

This temptation story comes early in both Matthew and Luke (and in the short account in Mark).  Literary critics would say that the hero must be tried before he sets out to rescue the princess held by a giant in a castle.  Jesus has no followers as yet.  He has just been baptized and heard the voice from heaven declaring him to be God’s chosen son.  This is his trial before the devil in his incarnation as tempter.

The most important temptation is without a doubt the second one.  The devil “led him up” (to a mountain top? Or perhaps to heaven?) and showed him all the kingdoms of the world.  If he will worship the devil he may have all of this for himself.  This can only be the temptation to storm the world by might.  It is Mao’s adage that power comes from the barrel of a gun.  It is the idea behind the “National Security Strategy of the United States” released by the White House in September of 2002.  It is the megalomania of the document prepared by a special commission chaired by Donald Rumsfeld on the “United States National Security Space Management and Organization” of January, 2001. The latter proposes to give the United States the military technology to deny the use of space to all other nations and to enable the United States to devastate any land on earth without the need for staging bases in nearby countries.  This is Mao to the Nth power.  To this temptation Jesus answered, “Worship the Lord your God and serve only him” (Lk 4:8).

The rabbis tell a story of how when the Israelites were dancing and carousing on the other side of the Red Sea seeing the utter destruction of the Egyptian army and their salvation by the outstretched arm of YHWH.  The angels came to the Lord and said, Why don’t we celebrate the salvation of your people also here in heaven?  The Lord answered, How can I celebrate when countless Egyptians my creatures were drowned in the Red Sea?  God who created all living beings and enjoys each and every one down to the humblest worm or beetle cannot wish the destruction of any, even those labeled “terrorists” by the greatest military machine on earth.

The only right way to carry out his ministry was by doing what was right, regardless of its power in the short run.  Jesus rejected the temptation of the short cuts offered by power, whether military, political or economic.  Should we not, individually and as a nation, follow Jesus and reject the temptation of the devil?  This can only be done when one has faith, faith that God wishes the best for us and for all of God’s creatures.  Jesus proved his faith before the devil in the desert and showed it in a powerful way in Gethsemane as his show-down with the authorities approached.  This is the faith we his followers are to imitate.

If you found this lectionary helpful, please consider contributing to Process & Faith by making a donation or becoming a member.